November 20, 2026 Nine years doesn’t make you independent. And a Board review doesn’t make you effective.
COMMENT
The Financial Reporting Council’s latest review found that Chair independence, Chair tenure and annual Board performance reviews were the most common areas of departure from the UK Corporate Governance Code. Thirty-nine of the 100 companies reviewed departed from at least one provision.
Under the Code, companies that have failed to comply are required to explain why. However, for me, the more important question is whether we have become too focused on demonstrating that the mechanics of good governance are in place, rather than asking whether they are producing better governance.
Being good at evidencing governance alone is not the same thing as being well governed.
The Code matters. It provides a useful framework and a common articulation of what good governance should broadly look like. But it is necessarily generic. No Code can know the personalities around a particular Board table, the quality of the relationships between them, where challenge is weak, how decisions are really made or what that organisation needs at a particular point in its development.
That is where judgement comes in. For the clients we work with at Elemental CoSec, I am much more interested in whether governance is effective than whether it is cosmetically perfect. That distinction runs through what follows: what makes a Board review worthwhile, how the Company Secretary can improve effectiveness throughout the year, and why independence cannot be measured by tenure alone.
A Board effectiveness review has no inherent value
I support Board effectiveness reviews when they have a purpose. What I question is the assumption that the process itself has inherent value simply because it has been completed.
The formula will be familiar. Questionnaires. Interviews. A report. And, after a considerable investment of Board time and money, we discover that papers should be shorter, more time should be spent on strategy and non-executive directors (NEDs) would welcome more opportunity for discussion.
None of that is necessarily wrong. But if everyone around the Board table knew it already, what exactly has been achieved?
External facilitation can be genuinely valuable. A good evaluator can bring objectivity, comparative experience and permission to ask questions an organisation has stopped asking itself. But the word “external” is not a guarantee of insight. A reviewer who spends a relatively short period with a Board may struggle to get under the skin of the organisation, its relationships and, crucially, the difference between how governance is supposed to work and how it actually works.
The Financial Reporting Council itself found that reporting too often describes what Boards reviewed, discussed or decided without explaining what changed as a result.
My test of a useful Board review is simple: what did we learn that mattered, and what are we doing differently because of it?
Sometimes the answer is not another broad review. It is a deep dive into what needs attention now. Are we getting sufficient challenge on strategy? Is the Board really seeing the information it needs? Is a committee adding value or just processing business? Does management respond differently because the NEDs challenged it?
Find the issue. Get underneath it. Do something useful with the answer. The test is what changes in the boardroom, not what was produced.
The Company Secretary should know before the Board evaluator does
This is where I think we consistently underestimate the role of an experienced Company Secretary.
The CoSec has something even an excellent periodic evaluator cannot easily replicate: continuity, organisational knowledge and a position at the centre of an extraordinarily complex stakeholder map.
Company Secretaries see the Chair, CEO, NEDs and executives operating over time. They see Board and committee dynamics. They work across advisers, investors, regulators and the people throughout the organisation who generate the information on which directors rely. They know what happened before the meeting, what happened in the room and whether anything actually happened afterwards.
But seeing it is only half the job. A good CoSec should be actively improving Board effectiveness throughout the year, not waiting for an annual review to diagnose it.
That might mean challenging an executive on a poor paper before the Board sees it. It might mean telling the Chair that the agenda is squeezing out the discussions that really matter. It can mean encouraging a NED to keep pursuing an uncomfortable question, improving information flows or recognising that ostensibly “good” Board dynamics are actually suppressing constructive disagreement.
Much of the best governance work happens through those relationships, quietly and continuously. It requires organisational intelligence, credibility and enough trust to say things that are not always comfortable to hear.
If the annual effectiveness review is the first time a Board discovers it has a problem, I would be asking what has been happening for the other eleven months.
For us at Elemental, the Company Secretary is not the Board’s governance scorekeeper. The role is far more valuable than that. Done properly, the Company Secretary is actively shaping the environment in which good decisions, effective challenge and accountability happen.
Nine years measures tenure. It does not measure independence.
I have the same difficulty with relying on an overly formulaic approach to tenure.
The Code says the Chair should not remain in post beyond nine years from first appointment to the Board, subject to limited flexibility, including to support effective succession planning and the development of a diverse Board.
There is a legitimate concern behind that provision. Familiarity can compromise independence. Relationships become comfortable. A Chair can become too identified with a management team or with a strategy they helped to create. But none of this suddenly happens at nine years.
What actually matters is conduct and behaviour. Does the Chair still hold the CEO to account? Are they intellectually curious? Are they prepared to revisit positions they previously supported? Do they make space for genuinely dissenting views? Or have they become too comfortable to challenge?
And we need to be intellectually consistent about the reverse proposition.
A newly appointed NED is not inherently independent in any meaningful sense simply because they are new. A NED who has been on the Board for two or three years but instinctively sides with management, avoids difficult conversations or contributes little effective challenge may satisfy every tenure test and still add very little independent judgement. Meanwhile, somebody approaching nine years may remain the person around the table most willing to test assumptions and say what others will not.
That exposes the weakness in using tenure as a proxy for independence.
Nine years is easy to measure. Independence is much harder. The danger is allowing what is easily measurable to displace what actually matters.
The Code is a starting point, not an instruction manual
None of this is an argument against the UK Corporate Governance Code. Instead, I think it is an argument for applying it more intelligently.
The Financial Reporting Council itself says the guidance is intended to stimulate Boards’ thinking and should not be used as a tick-box list. It says governance should be proportionate and appropriate to the company. I think we should take that seriously.
Sometimes the right answer is straightforward adherence. Sometimes it is a conscious departure because, having understood what the provision is trying to achieve, the Board has concluded there is a better way of achieving the underlying governance outcome for its circumstances.
I would rather see a Board make an intelligent, defensible departure from the Code than comply with something that adds little value simply because ticking the box is easier.
That requires more rigour, not less. You have to understand the purpose behind the provision, the risk created by departing from it and why your alternative genuinely works. And you have to be prepared to explain that decision properly.
At Elemental CoSec, I don’t want to just tell a Board what the Code says. They can read it. Our job is to understand the organisation, its people, relationships, risks and behaviours well enough to know what good looks like for that organisation, and then help its Board deliver it.
Good governance should be proportionate, pragmatic and designed around the organisation in front of you. It should improve decisions and sharpen challenge, not simply produce evidence that a process has taken place.
Applying the Code intelligently requires more judgement than simply complying with it. That means judging a Board review by what changes, independence by the challenge a director brings, and the Company Secretary’s contribution by how the Board works throughout the year. That is the difference between evidencing governance and making it effective.
About the author
Kate Owen is Director of Governance at Elemental CoSec and a Fellow of the Chartered Governance Institute. She has worked in the legal and company secretarial sector since 2004, advising financial services companies, private businesses, public authority bodies and not-for-profit organisations on governance frameworks and company secretarial requirements. Visit here to find out more and contact Kate.
